What ever happened to sugar?
OK, I realize that I may offend some people with this post, but this subject is something I feel strongly about. In the past, I never really thought much about artificial sweeteners except to avoid them, which was easy when all they used to be in was diet soda and the little packets that were either pink or blue (thanks – I’ll take the white one). But recently it is amazing just how many products this stuff has found its way into and how many people think it is a healthy low calorie alternative, or just eat it without really thinking about it. Let’s face it; while it may be lower in calories, it probably is not healthy. OK, so there is conflicting evidence out there: some say its OK, others say it will give you cancer. So what is the truth? Well, we might not know for sure for some time … but I think there is plenty of cause for caution just based on common sense.
The five most common artificial sweeteners found in all kinds of products today are sucralose, aspartame, saccharin, neotame, and acesulfame potassium. Ironically, out of these, the two most common sweeteners, sucralose and aspartame, might also be the most dangerous. Did you know that sucralose, aka Splenda, is made by chemically altering sugar with chlorine? Just recently I was reading a low fat zucchini bread recipe and it calls for a 1/2 cup of Splenda in the mix and 6 packets of Splenda to be sprinkled on top of the bread. Mmmm … chlorine bread. Anyway, there is plenty of scientific stuff out there showing these artificial sweeteners are bad … but you don’t need me to tell you that.
But beyond the fact that this stuff is probably bad for you, did you know that it might not even help you lose weight? Some studies show that artificial sweeteners actually leave you feeling hungrier causing you to consume more calories than if you just ate the real deal to begin with, and other studies show that slows down the body’s metabolism … so even if you refrain from eating more, your body is slowing down the processing of what you did eat. Probably unhealthy and it may not even work? Sounds like a bum deal to me. Honestly, do you think you can beat Mother Nature?
This artificial sweetener craze has become an epidemic (in my opinion) … from blogs, to recipes, and even my beloved Biggest Loser. This crap is taking over! But again, putting aside the scientific stuff, ask yourself … does it make sense to consume large amounts of man made chemicals in the name of ‘health’? Can this lovely sweet chlorine byproduct actually be good for me? If you truly feel the balance of the risks is acceptable – then maybe it is worth it for you. For example, a morbidly obese person or someone with diabetes could probably justify the risks. But for the rest of us, my mantra is if you want to be healthy and loose weight - just don’t eat the bread, or whatever. Or if you choose to eat it, eat a smaller portion without the artificial sweetener. Or hell, just eat it and be fat. I would personally prefer that to the risk of ingesting this stuff. But, at the end of the day, that is why artificial sweetners are so popular. It is a quick fix. It is a way to have your cake and eat it too (literally and figuratively). The marketers love this stuff: ‘buy our product, it tastes almost the same but has no calories.’ True enough, but what they don’t mention is the long term health risks or the short term effects of eating more and a slower metabolism.
As I said – just my opinion. I’d love to hear yours.
Stay Strong,
Kristi

22 Comments